| Varsity Champions |
| Season |
Champion |
Tournament Format |
Tournament Host |
Summary |
| Fall 2011 |
Bishop Dunn Memorial |
2 groups of 3 teams / winner of each group plays for championship |
St. Stephen's at Warwick Town Park and Sacred Heart Newburgh at Mt. Airy Sports Complex |
Bishop Dunn defeated Sacred Heart Monroe 6-0 in the final to retain their championship. |
| Spring 2011 |
Bishop Dunn Memorial  |
5 team single elimination playoffs |
|
Bishop Dunn defeated Sacred Heart Newburgh in the semifinals and won the championship game 4-1 over Sacred Heart Monroe. |
| Fall 2010 |
Sacred Heart Monroe  |
2 groups of 3 teams / winner of each group plays for championship |
St. Stephen's at Warwick Town Park |
Sacred Heart Monroe defeated Sacred Heart Newburgh 5-0 in the final. |
| Spring 2010 |
Our Lady of Mt. Carmel |
3 team round robin |
St. Stephen's at Warwick Town Park |
The Panthers dominated in their two games to win the championship. |
| Fall 2009 |
Most Precious Blood |
2 groups of 3 teams / winner of each group plays for championship |
Our Lady of Mt. Carmel |
MPB met Mt. Carmel in the final. The score was tied 1-1 after regular time, and 2-2 after extra time. MPB prevailed in a penalty kick shootout. |
| Spring 2009 |
Our Lady of Mt. Carmel |
3 team round robin |
Sacred Heart Newburgh at Cronomer Hill Park |
The Panthers went undefeated in their two games to complete the fall/spring sweep. |
| Fall 2008 |
Our Lady of Mt. Carmel |
6 team round robin |
St. Stephen's at Warwick Town Park |
Mt. Carmel and St. Joseph's met in the last game of the tournament with the championship on the line. Mt. Carmel edged out St. Joseph's. |
| Spring 2008 |
Sacred Heart Newburgh |
4 team round robin |
Sacred Heart Monroe at PrimoSports |
The Hornets won all three of their games to claim the championship. |
| Fall 2007 |
Most Precious Blood |
6 team round robin |
St. Stephen's at Warwick Town Park |
Most Precious Blood and Mt. Carmel finished even on points after five games. MPB won the tie breaker based on most goals scored to claim the championship. |
| Fall 2006 |
St. Joseph's |
5 team round robin |
Sacred Heart Newburgh at Delano Hitch |
|
| Spring 2005 |
Sacred Heart Monroe |
|
|
|